The London Broker: Why the Property Ladder Is Freezing From the Top Down
For years, the debate around Britain's housing market has focused on first-time buyers struggling to get onto the property ladder. In this analysis, first published in Prime Resi, LPF member Rupert Collingwood, Founder of The London Broker, argues that the more significant challenge now lies further up the chain, where many homeowners are finding it increasingly difficult to move on from the properties they already own.
Drawing on three decades of structural change across the UK housing market, Rupert examines how declining mobility is creating a chain-wide blockage with implications for homeowners, developers, agents and investors. He also considers why, in a less liquid market, relationships and the ability to connect the right buyer with the right property are becoming more valuable than ever.
For the last two decades, the British housing debate has revolved around one dominant idea: first-time buyers can no longer get on the ladder.
That is true to an extent, but I increasingly believe it is no longer the market’s biggest problem.
The more consequential issue today sits higher up the chain. Britain’s housing market is no longer simply struggling to help younger buyers purchase their first home. It is struggling to help older owners move on from the homes they already have.
I’ve produced a wider thesis on this, covering thirty years of structural change across the UK housing market, which can be read at RupertCollingwood.com. But the simplest version is this: the market has become less liquid, less rational, and less forgiving than the one that existed in the late 1990s.
Over the last three decades, house prices have significantly outpaced earnings growth, fundamentally changing the financial reality of moving home. At the same time, we have layered increasing transaction taxes onto housing, stretched mortgage terms to maintain affordability, and created a market where many owners no longer view moving as financially sensible.
“Many ordinary family homes, particularly at the upper-middle levels of the market, are becoming increasingly difficult to transact unless they are exceptional.”
Much of the public discussion still assumes there is an endless shortage of large family houses. In reality, many ordinary family homes, particularly at the upper-middle levels of the market, are becoming increasingly difficult to transact unless they are exceptional.
Families are smaller. Buyers are older. Running costs matter more. Mortgage rates are no longer artificially cheap. Stamp duty has become a major financial event in itself.
At the same time, the downsizer market, which many older homeowners are expected to rely upon, barely functions properly.
Most downsizers do not want tiny retirement flats, expensive service charges, or complex leasehold structures. They want good-quality smaller houses, manageable gardens, parking, transport links, proximity to family, and homes that still allow them to live well.
The problem is that this is exactly the same stock younger families are also competing for.
The result is a chain-wide blockage. Older owners stay put because they cannot find the right next move, or because the financial logic of moving no longer works. Younger families then cannot access larger homes, restricting movement lower down the ladder.
The chain is increasingly freezing from the top, not the bottom.
At the same time, England has underbuilt homes for decades, and even where demand exists, the right housing often does not.
This is why the current market can feel simultaneously expensive and stagnant. There is still demand. There is still wealth. There are still transactions. But mobility has deteriorated sharply.
And when markets become less liquid, relationships become more important.
This is one of the reasons we are seeing increasing collaboration between agents, brokers and cross-border networks. This is especially true within prime markets where buyer pools are smaller, more international and more specific. Matching the right buyer to the right property is becoming far more valuable than simply generating the highest volume of enquiries.
“The portal era optimised for visibility. The next phase of the market will increasingly optimise for relevance.”
But if we want the market to function more efficiently again, we need to stop viewing the housing crisis purely through the lens of first-time buyers.
In many ways, the people most stuck within the housing market today are no longer trying to get on the ladder.
They are trying to get off it.
About The London Broker
The London Broker is a collective of leading independent property brokers operating across London and internationally.
Through a shared platform, our brokers combine their experience, relationships and local knowledge to provide clients with clear advice and a consistent, high-quality service across sales, lettings and acquisition.
get in touch
To find out more about The London Broker, please contact the team using the details below:
T: +44 20 7193 9969
E: enquiries@thelondonbroker.com
Visit their website: www.thelondonbroker.com